Notifiing the Minister
for Social Welfare

image_print
Section 4 (11) of the Casual Trading Act, 1995 requires a local authority to notify the Minister for Social Welfare of the name and address of a person to whom a casual trading licence was granted and the conditions of the licence.

Casual Trading Act 1995

Casual Trading Licences.

Section 4(11)

A local authority is therefore obliged to inform the Dept. of Social Protection of the granting of a casual trading licence to an individual and the duration of that licence. However a local authority is not required to provide details of when and whom was trading under a licence on a particular day for the duration of that licence. It is the responsibility of each individual market trader to keep records and provide those records to the Dept. of Social Protection when making an application for benefits.
If a local authority were to receive a request from the Dept. of Social Protection or a request from the Guardai in relation to working while claiming benefits, a local authority would have to provide any attendance records pertaining to that licence.

Market Trading and Social Welfare Payments

A casual trading licence may be granted to an individual, a small business or a limited company. In each case a licence is granted to a named individual who may identify named ‘servants or agents’ who may also operate under that licence. A market trader can therefore be either self-employed or an employee of the owner of a licence. The rules that apply to social welfare payments differ for self-employed and employed persons.

Self-employed Market Traders

Income From Self-employment and the Means Test

The earnings from market trading will be assessed in the means test for Jobseeker’s Allowance. The assessment must reflect the income you may reasonably be expected to get from your business over the next 12 months. Income for the last 12 months will be taken as a guide but allowing for any factors which it is known will vary. You should be prepared to discuss these factors when you are assessed for Jobseeker’s Allowance.
Earnings are assessed as gross income less work related expenses over 12 months. Your expected annual earnings from self-employment is divided by 52 to find your weekly means from self-employment. Any ‘drawings’ (wages) you take from the business is not an allowable expense. If your ‘drawings’ from the business are greater than the level of income calculated, the ‘drawings’ are assessed as cash income. There is no exhaustive list of all business expenses allowed because expenses vary with the nature and extent of the self-employment. However the following are the main allowable expenses in most cases:
Materials (supplies costs)
Motor running costs (portion applicable to business)
Depreciation of machinery or equipment
Insurance relating to the business
Telephone (portion applicable to business)
Lighting and heating (for business and not domestic use)
Advertising
Bank charges
Stationery
Any other costs associated with running the business (household running costs are not allowed as deductions against business profit)
To prove the level of income from your business you must give your receipts and payments (documentation showing money coming in and out of your business) or accounts to the person dealing with your application in your social welfare local office.

When you apply for Jobseeker’s Allowance

Usually, you will be asked for your receipts and payments or accounts for the current and previous year. For example, if you apply for Jobseeker’s Allowance in April 2015 you will be asked for your receipts and payments from January to April 2015 and for 2014. However, in certain cases you may be required to show accounts for the last two or more years.

Supplementary Welfare Allowance

You may qualify for Supplementary Welfare Allowance while you are waiting to be assessed for a jobseeker’s payment or if you don’t qualify for a jobseeker’s payment.
Supplementary Welfare Allowance provides a basic weekly allowance to eligible people who have little or no income. If your weekly income is below the Supplementary Welfare Allowance rate for your family size, a payment may be made to bring your income up to the appropriate Supplementary Welfare Allowance rate.
You cannot get Supplementary Welfare Allowance if you are working more than 30 hours per week. If you have claimed a jobseeker’s payment but it has not yet been paid and you have no other income, you may qualify for Supplementary Welfare Allowance while you are awaiting payment.

Employed Market Traders

Jobseeker’s Allowance and Work

In order to get Jobseeker’s Allowance you must be unemployed. You must also be capable of, available for, and genuinely seeking work to qualify for Jobseeker’s Allowance – and you must be able to show evidence of this to the Department of Social Protection. However, there are circumstances in which you can do some work and get Jobseeker’s Allowance. Income from work affects the amount of Jobseeker’s Allowance you get.
If you get part-time or casual work (up to and including 3 days per week), you may still be paid Jobseeker’s Allowance for the other days. However, you must show that you are trying to get full-time employment. If your employer reduces your days at work to 3 days week or less, you may get Jobseeker’s Allowance for the other days. You must meet the other conditions that apply to Jobseeker’s Allowance, for example, you must satisfy a means test.
If you have been getting long-term Jobseeker’s Allowance (over 390 days or 15 months) and you take up part-time work for less than 24 hours a week you may be eligible for the Part-time Job Incentive Scheme (PTJI). This scheme allows you to take up part-time work and get a special weekly allowance instead of your jobseeker’s payment.
Posted in Casual Trading Licence | Comments Off on Notifiing the Minister
for Social Welfare

Online Applications
& Payments

image_print

Paper & Online Applications

Casual trading licence applications should be made available to the public in paper and electronic form. Paper applications forms should be available at local authority buildings and be available to download from a local authority’s website. Local authorities are also required by the Services Directive to provide an online application form, including an online payment facility.

EU Services Directive Guide for Local Authorities

(Guideline 2)

EU Services Directive 2006/123/EC

Procedures by Electronic Means

[Art. 8 (1)]

European Union (Provision of Services) Regulations 2010

Completion of certain procedures by electronic means

Article 32.(1)

Posted in Casual Trading Licence | Comments Off on Online Applications
& Payments

Displaying a
Licence Number

image_print

Displaying a Casual Trading Licence Number

During the passage of the 1994 Casual Trading Bill through Seanad Eireann, it was agreed that a casual trader would only be required to display their licence number on their stall, rather than the whole licence as originally envisaged. It was considered to much of a security risk to ask a casual trader to display their home address on their stall, thereby informing passersby that their home may be unoccupied on market day.
All other information relating to the owner of the licence may be obtained from their licence number. However Casual Traders are still required to produce their licence to any person upon request. Failure to display a licence number or to provide a licence to any person upon request is an offence under the 95 Act. These requirements are contained in section 5(1)(a)(b)and (c) of the Casual Trading Act 1995.

Seanad Eirean – Volume 144 – 11 July, 1995

Casual Trading Bill, 1994; Second Stage.

Casual Trading Act 1995

Display of Casual Trading Licences.

Section 5—(1)

Posted in Casual Trading Licence | Comments Off on Displaying a
Licence Number

Licence &
Stallage Fees

image_print

Licence Fees

The Casual Trading Act 1995 provides a local authority with an entitlement to charge a fee for a casual trading licence and to fix fees for different circumstances and different classes of persons.

Licence Fees for Different Sets of Circumstances

A local authority may licence casual trading in three sets of circumstances.
1) In the functional area of a local authority,
2) In a designated Casual Trading Area,
3) or at an event.
These three sets of circumstances are set out in section 4, of the Casual Trading Act 1995. A local authority may charge a licence fee appropriate to these individual circumstances.

Casual Trading Act 1995

Casual Trading Licences.

Licence Fees for Different Classes of Persons

A casual trading licence may be granted to persons selling different classes of goods that may require different types of documentation. The type of goods sold at a market may be divided into four categories.
1) Hot Food
2) Slow Food
3) Crafts, Second Hand and Assorted Goods
4) Livestock
A local authority may charge a licence fee appropriate to the type of goods sold.

Casual Trading Act 1995

Section 6—(2)

Section 6—(2)(d)

The Casual Trading Act 1995 also states that when a local authority is fixing fees it may have regard to the facilities and services it provides to casual traders.

Casual Trading Act 1995

Section 6—(4)

The use of the word ‘may’ in section 6(2)(d) acts only as a recommendation that licence fees be linked to the cost of facilities. The lack of an obligation in this part of the act has led to large variations in the level of fees charged by local authorities.
In 2002, Mary Harney in her capacity as Minister for Trade Enterprise and Employment commissioned a report on the implementation of the casual trading act by local authorities. The Competition Authority Report found that the fees set by local authorities varied from €13 to €1777.

The Competition Authority Report 2002

Variation in Fee Levels Relationship to Number of Traders

The report also found that local authorities were setting their licence fees using three different methods.

The Competition Authority Report 2002

Fee-setting and Allocation of Licences

A High Court judgement in 2001, known as the ‘Taxi Case’, ruled that a licence fee set by a local authority can only cover the cost of issuing a licence.

The Competition Authority Report 2002

The report went on to make four recommendations with regard to licence fees.
1) Licence fees should be based solely on the administrative cost of issuing a licence and the cost of facilities.
2) The word ‘may’ in section 6 (2)(d) of the 95 Act should be changed to ‘shall’ thereby creating an obligation on local authorities to directly link licence fees to the cost of facilities.
3) A local authority should make it’s licence fees public along with a breakdown of the associated costs.
4) There should be an amendment to the Casual Trading Act 1995 to allow fees to be challenged in the district and circuit court, as are all other aspects of bye-laws.

Recommendations 5, 6, 9 & 10 of the Competition Authority Report

Transparency

The report also recommended the introduction of Statutory Ministerial guidelines that would provide for the consistent implementation of the Casual Trading Act 1995 by local authorities.

Consistency Guidelines

Following the publication of the Competition Authority Report in 2002, Mary Harney went on to form the ‘Consumer Strategy Group’ that reported in 2005. The main objective of the CSG report was to put forward recommendations that would form a scheme of a bill, that became the Consumer Protection Act 2007. Chapter 3 of the CSG report mentioned the earlier Competition Authority Report and some of its recommendations.

Consumer Strategy Report, April 2005

Chapter 3

The Retail Sector

Chapter 3.3 Fruit & Vegetables

Chapter 17 of the CSG Report recommended that statutory Guidelines should be put in place via an amendment to the Casual Trading Act 1995.

Chapter 17

Recommendations and Action Plan

Key recommendations

The Consumer Strategy Group subsequently provided Statutory Ministerial Guidelines through an amendment to the Casual Trading Act 1995. The amendment to section 6 of the act was created via section 98 of the Consumer Protection Act 2007. Section 98 inserted section 6A into the 95 Act and states that a local authority making bye-laws under that section shall have regard to guidelines. The word ‘shall’ rather than ‘may’ creating a legal obligation on local authorities to implement guidelines.

The Consumer Protection Act 2007

Section 98.— Amendment of Casual Trading Act 1995.

The following section is inserted after Section 6 of the Casual Trading Act 1995:

Guidelines with respect to performance of functions under Section 6.

With regard to licence fees and the competition authority’s recommendations. Statutory guidelines included three of the four recommendations previously mentioned in the Competition Authority Report.
1) Local authorities can not use licence fees as a revenue stream and fees should be directly linked to the cost of facilities. This guideline effectively substituted the word ‘shall’ (should) for ‘may’ in section 6(4) of the 95 act.
2) In terms of transparency, a local authority has to provide a written break down of costs, showing how their fees are set and the costs of the facilities provided to market traders.

Casual Trading Act 1995 Guidelines for Local Authorities

Guideline 11.

Fees for Casual Trading under section 6 (2) (d)

There is no provision in the guidelines for appealing the level of licence fees in the district or circuit courts. The only way to appeal licence fees is by judicial review. The Competition Authority report commented on this situation in Chapter 2.

Competition Authority Report

Chapter 2

The Casual Trading Act 1995

An appeal to the courts may also argue that excessive licence fees are a barrier to trade and a restriction on the exercise of a market right under article 43.2.2 of the constitution. This was also mentioned in the Competition Authority’s report.

Competition Authority Report

Chapter 9

Methods for Setting Fees

The interplay between the Casual Trading Act and market property rights is also referred to in statutory ministerial guidelines.

Casual Trading Act 1995 Guidelines for Local Authorities

Guideline 6.

Market Rights

The Services Directive

In 2009 the Dept. for Enterprise Trade and Employment issued further guidance with respect to the European Services Directive which came into force in 2010. The guidelines refer to Articles of the European Services Directive 2006/123/EC and their effect of on casual trading. The EU Services Directive was transposed into Irish law via Statutory Instrument 533, European Union (Provision of Services) Regulations 2010.
The Services Directive guidelines discuss authorisation procedures or the granting of a casual trading licence. One aspect of these guidelines relates to the fee a local authority can charge for a casual trading licence.
The Services Directive Guidelines and the legislation on which they are based clearly state that only the administrative costs associated with an application can be charged in fees.

EU Services Directive Guide for Local Authorities

Guideline 10

EU Services Directive 2006/123/EC

Authorization procedures [Article 13 (2)]

Irish Law

European Union (Provision of Services) Regulations 2010

General requirements for authorisation schemes

The Services Directive effectively made it illegal to include the cost of facilities in a licence fee. This created something of a problem as a licence fee could no longer cover the cost of facilities.
The solution was to separate the Casual Trading Act’s Licence fee into two separate fees.
The first fee covers the cost of processing an application and producing a licence. This can continue to be called a licence fee.
The second fee is directly linked to the cost of facilities, this fee is historically called Stallage.
‘Stallage’ is defined as the right to erect a stall or stalls at a fair or market, or the rent toll or fee paid for a stall.
A local authority cannot use stallage fees as a revenue for profit stream; fees should be directly related to the cost of the facilities provided.
Those facilities may include the following:
1) The Space allocated for trading purposes
2) Cost of the Market Manager and other Authorized Officers
3) Cost of rubbish collection produced by the market
4) Cost of signage and other market fixtures and fittings.

Summary

The licence fee set by bye-law under section 6(2)(d) of the Casual Trading Act 1995 shall only cover the cost of issuing the licence and the direct cost of facilities [Section 6 (2)(4)].
A licence fee set by bye-law under the Casual Trading Act 1995 can be split into two fees, a licence fee and a stallage fee.
A licence fee can only cover the cost of processing an application and producing a licence (administration).
A Stallage fee can only cover the cost of facilities directly linked to the running of the fair or market.
Licence and stallage fees cannot be used as a revenue stream, a market has to be run on a cost neutral not-for-profit basis.
A local authority must make it’s licence fees public and provide a written break down and calculation of costs.
There is no provision under the Casual Trading Act to challenge fees in the District or Circuit Court. An appeal may be made via judicial review.
If a local authority, in fixing a fee, fixed a fee that no reasonable authority could fix, or if in the course of its fee-fixing procedures a local authority had been motivated by bias, or had taken into account matters which it ought not to have taken into account, or if the fee represented a restriction on the exercise of a market property right, the bye-law would be capable of being struck down on judicial review.
Posted in Licence & Stallage Fees | Comments Off on Licence &
Stallage Fees